Matches in ESWC 2020 for { ?s ?p The paper concerns Industry 4.0 Knowledge Graph that depicts the status of standards, reference frameworks and concerns for Industry 4.0. The potential application of the resource is to enable newcomers and experts to get the recent knowledge on how to implement Industry 4.0 systems. Some chosen application scenarios are also presented in the paper. The motivation of the paper is clear and well described. The idea behind the I40KG is also valid as this method for aggregation of diverse resources (that should be “living” resources) may provide its timeliness. The research goal is provided within the paper and the structure of the paper is aligned to meet the goal. The paper does not include detailed methodology related to the development of the graph, however some insights into the research process are given. It would be appreciated to provide insights into assessment of completeness of the approach. Related work: related work on knowledge base design and knowledge graph maintenance seems to be missing. The maintenance process is crucial to make the graph stay up to date and fulfill the requirements specified. In my opinion, the description of processes of updating, extending and maintaining the graph is the weakest part of the paper. Quality: how the Knowledge Graph was evaluated for completeness? How to know that no important guidelines are missing, and all knowledge is covered? How is the provenance of diverse resources described while presenting data to the user? What in case some part of resources are not valid anymore? Visualization: it is appreciated that I40KG comes with visualizations enabling non-semantic experts’ interaction with the graph. However, some more detail on architecture of all elements enabling for production of visualizations would be needed.". }
Showing items 1 to 1 of
1
with 100 items per page.
- Paper.169_Review.1 hasContent "The paper concerns Industry 4.0 Knowledge Graph that depicts the status of standards, reference frameworks and concerns for Industry 4.0. The potential application of the resource is to enable newcomers and experts to get the recent knowledge on how to implement Industry 4.0 systems. Some chosen application scenarios are also presented in the paper. The motivation of the paper is clear and well described. The idea behind the I40KG is also valid as this method for aggregation of diverse resources (that should be “living” resources) may provide its timeliness. The research goal is provided within the paper and the structure of the paper is aligned to meet the goal. The paper does not include detailed methodology related to the development of the graph, however some insights into the research process are given. It would be appreciated to provide insights into assessment of completeness of the approach. Related work: related work on knowledge base design and knowledge graph maintenance seems to be missing. The maintenance process is crucial to make the graph stay up to date and fulfill the requirements specified. In my opinion, the description of processes of updating, extending and maintaining the graph is the weakest part of the paper. Quality: how the Knowledge Graph was evaluated for completeness? How to know that no important guidelines are missing, and all knowledge is covered? How is the provenance of diverse resources described while presenting data to the user? What in case some part of resources are not valid anymore? Visualization: it is appreciated that I40KG comes with visualizations enabling non-semantic experts’ interaction with the graph. However, some more detail on architecture of all elements enabling for production of visualizations would be needed."".