Matches in ESWC 2020 for { ?s ?p ?o. }
- Author.150.7 type RoleDuringEvent.
- Author.150.7 label "Stefan Decker, 7th Author for Paper 150".
- Author.150.7 withRole PublishingRole.
- Author.150.7 isHeldBy Stefan_Decker.
- Lars_C._Gleim type Person.
- Lars_C._Gleim name "Lars C. Gleim".
- Lars_C._Gleim label "Lars C. Gleim".
- Lars_C._Gleim holdsRole Author.150.1.
- Rafael_Schimassek type Person.
- Rafael_Schimassek name "Rafael Schimassek".
- Rafael_Schimassek label "Rafael Schimassek".
- Rafael_Schimassek holdsRole Author.150.2.
- Dominik_Hüser type Person.
- Dominik_Hüser name "Dominik Hüser".
- Dominik_Hüser label "Dominik Hüser".
- Dominik_Hüser holdsRole Author.150.3.
- Maximilian_Peters type Person.
- Maximilian_Peters name "Maximilian Peters".
- Maximilian_Peters label "Maximilian Peters".
- Maximilian_Peters holdsRole Author.150.4.
- Christoph_Krämer type Person.
- Christoph_Krämer name "Christoph Krämer".
- Christoph_Krämer label "Christoph Krämer".
- Christoph_Krämer holdsRole Author.150.5.
- Stefan_Decker type Person.
- Stefan_Decker name "Stefan Decker".
- Stefan_Decker label "Stefan Decker".
- Stefan_Decker holdsRole Author.150.7.
- Stefan_Decker holdsRole Author.167.3.
- Author.167.3 type RoleDuringEvent.
- Author.167.3 label "Stefan Decker, 3rd Author for Paper 167".
- Author.167.3 withRole PublishingRole.
- Author.167.3 isHeldBy Stefan_Decker.
- Victor_de_Boer type Person.
- Victor_de_Boer name "Victor de Boer".
- Victor_de_Boer label "Victor de Boer".
- Victor_de_Boer holdsRole Paper.150_Review.0_Reviewer.
- Victor_de_Boer mbox mailto:v.de.boer@vu.nl.
- Paper.150_Review.0_Reviewer type RoleDuringEvent.
- Paper.150_Review.0_Reviewer label "Victor de Boer, Reviewer for Paper 150".
- Paper.150_Review.0_Reviewer withRole ReviewerRole.
- Paper.150_Review.0_Reviewer withRole NonAnonymousReviewerRole.
- Paper.150_Review.0_Reviewer isHeldBy Victor_de_Boer.
- Paper.150_Review.0 type ReviewVersion.
- Paper.150_Review.0 issued "2001-02-04T11:51:00.000Z".
- Paper.150_Review.0 creator Paper.150_Review.0_Reviewer.
- Paper.150_Review.0 hasRating ReviewRating.1.
- Paper.150_Review.0 hasReviewerConfidence ReviewerConfidence.3.
- Paper.150_Review.0 reviews Paper.150.
- Paper.150_Review.0 issuedAt easychair.org.
- Paper.150_Review.0 issuedFor Conference.
- Paper.150_Review.0 releasedBy Conference.
- Paper.150_Review.0 hasContent "This paper presents a method for recommending new properties to Wikidata editors that can be added to enrich existing Wikidata entities. The method is designed to be effective (provide relevant properties) and efficient (in terms of computational resources). It uses a trie-based representation of the property space to efficiently calculate support for rules that are then used to recommend new properties. The paper furthermore presents various "backoff" strategies to increase the performance. The evaluation compares the method to the currently implemented Wikidata property recommender and compares different backoff variants. The paper presents a clear research problem, improving a service for a crucial and central semantic resource. The method itself is an interesting and novel combination of existing trie-methods to order properties in large knowledge graphs. The evaluation is extensive and well-described. The paper itself is well-written and easy to follow. A few points of concern: - In section 3, the recommendation task is defined to predict a relevant property, given existing properties of an item. This is a narrow definition the task, since it would make sense that not only properties, but also values could be considered. In fact, this is mentioned in the second-to-last sentence of the paper for future work. I appreciate that this is at least addressed, but I suggest to do this in section 3 already and to explain why this was not chosen in this work. - The evaluation only presents statistical comparisons between the different variants and to the existing recommender. What would clearly be an interesting extension is a human evaluation of the recommender. Are the suggested properties appreciated and or used by the editors? This is more of a suggestion for future work, which can be addressed in this paper. Especially as this paper was submitted to the Social and Human Aspects of the Semantic Web Track. All in all, the user is missing from this paper. - Related to this, even though multiple metrics are used, what is missing is some insight into the type of properties that *are* recommended in one version and not in another version. This would give more insight into the behaviour of the method. - I am also missing some discussion about the applicability of the method to other knowledge graphs. The method is now tested on one specific one, but could be applied to arbitrary (RDF) knowledge graphs as is claimed by the authors. It is now unclear what properties of Wikidata make this approach work. It might be the case that there is a specific distribution of properties that is needed for this method? A second experiment on other graphs would increase the impact of the work. Overall, I think that although the research contribution is limited, the work is interesting and well-described with a good evaluation. typos: p2 conclouding -> concluding p3 realative -> relative p14 more then -> more than ** After rebuttal: I'd like to thank the authors for their responses. I understand some of the choices that were made as explained in the rebuttal. Overall, I still think that the paper presents an interesting method and is well-written. However, I still feel that for this track, the lack of users/humans is problematic, as well as the lack of research contribution. I will keep my score."".
- Paper.150_Review.1_Reviewer type RoleDuringEvent.
- Paper.150_Review.1_Reviewer label "Anonymous Reviewer for Paper 150".
- Paper.150_Review.1_Reviewer withRole ReviewerRole.
- Paper.150_Review.1_Reviewer withRole AnonymousReviewerRole.
- Paper.150_Review.1 type ReviewVersion.
- Paper.150_Review.1 issued "2001-02-06T09:09:00.000Z".
- Paper.150_Review.1 creator Paper.150_Review.1_Reviewer.
- Paper.150_Review.1 hasRating ReviewRating.1.
- Paper.150_Review.1 hasReviewerConfidence ReviewerConfidence.4.
- Paper.150_Review.1 reviews Paper.150.
- Paper.150_Review.1 issuedAt easychair.org.
- Paper.150_Review.1 issuedFor Conference.
- Paper.150_Review.1 releasedBy Conference.
- Paper.150_Review.1 hasContent "This paper presents a new approach to property recommendation of entities in Wikidata by using a tree-based data structure to store support of frequent property sets. The proposed approach is evaluated against the current property recommendation used for Wikidata and performs better on several metrics. Strengths 1) The paper presents a novel approach to property recommendation in knowledge-bases such as Wikidata. 2) The SchemaTree recommendation algorithm outperforms compared to the PropertySuggester. 3) The paper is well-written with minor grammar issues. Weaknesses 1) Although novel, the significance of the proposed approach looks limited given the incremental improvement (4%-6%) in results against the baseline. 2) It is unclear why the proposed approach was not compared with Balaraman et al. and Dessi & Atzori. 3) The presentation style of the paper can be improved by using consistent terminology (property, attribute, or predicate). ** After rebuttal: I thank the authors for their responses to reviewers' concerns. After going through other reviews and authors' responses I still think that the approach is novel; however, I will keep my score as it is due limitations of evaluation and significance of research contribution."".
- Paper.153 type SubmissionsPaper.
- Paper.153 label "ORCA: a Benchmark for Data Web Crawlers".
- Paper.153 title "ORCA: a Benchmark for Data Web Crawlers".
- Paper.153 issued "2001-12-04T14:46:00.000Z".
- Paper.153 authorList b0_g387.
- Paper.153 submission Paper.153.
- Paper.153 track Track.Resources%20Track.
- b0_g387 first Author.153.1.
- b0_g387 rest b0_g388.
- Author.153.1 type RoleDuringEvent.
- Author.153.1 label "Michael Röder, 1st Author for Paper 153".
- Author.153.1 withRole PublishingRole.
- Author.153.1 isHeldBy Michael_Röder.
- b0_g388 first Author.153.2.
- b0_g388 rest b0_g389.
- Author.153.2 type RoleDuringEvent.
- Author.153.2 label "Geraldo Souza, 2nd Author for Paper 153".
- Author.153.2 withRole PublishingRole.
- Author.153.2 isHeldBy Geraldo_Souza.
- b0_g389 first Author.153.3.
- b0_g389 rest b0_g390.
- Author.153.3 type RoleDuringEvent.
- Author.153.3 label "Denis Kuchelev, 3rd Author for Paper 153".
- Author.153.3 withRole PublishingRole.
- Author.153.3 isHeldBy Denis_Kuchelev.
- b0_g390 first Author.153.4.
- b0_g390 rest b0_g391.
- Author.153.4 type RoleDuringEvent.
- Author.153.4 label "Abdelmoneim Amer Desouki, 4th Author for Paper 153".
- Author.153.4 withRole PublishingRole.
- Author.153.4 isHeldBy Abdelmoneim_Amer_Desouki.
- b0_g391 first Author.153.5.
- b0_g391 rest nil.