Matches in DBpedia 2014 for { <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn> ?p ?o. }
Showing items 1 to 44 of
44
with 100 items per page.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn abstract "Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v. Winn, 09-987, was a case decided by the Supreme Court of the United States. The case was consolidated with Gale Garriott, Director, Arizona Department of Revenue, Petitioner v. Kathleen M. Winn, et al. (09-991).A group of Arizona taxpayers challenged a state law providing tax credits to people who donate to school tuition organizations providing scholarships to students attending private or religious schools. The taxpayers claimed a violation of the Establishment Clause. The District Court dismissed the case, holding that the taxpayers did not state a valid claim. The decision was reversed by the Ninth Circuit, which ruled that the respondents had standing to sue, citing Flast v. Cohen.The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that the plaintiffs did not have standing to bring suit. Writing for the majority, Justice Kennedy stated “this Court has rejected the general proposition that an individual who has paid taxes has a ‘continuing, legally cognizable interest in ensuring that those funds are not used by the Government in a way that violates the Constitution.’” Ultimately, the Supreme Court found that any damages or harm claimed by the taxpayers by virtue of simply being a taxpayer would be pure speculation because the issue at hand was a tax credit and not a government expenditure. Justice Scalia filed a concurring opinion, joined by Justice Thomas.In her dissent, Justice Kagan said “cash grants and targeted tax breaks are means of accomplishing the same government objective—to provide financial support to select individuals or organizations.” She further argued: “taxpayers should be able to challenge the subsidy.” The dissent was joined by Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, and Sotomayor. Bruce Peabody, a political science professor at Fairleigh Dickinson University, remarked “the case brought out four dissents, a signal that those justices were prepared to decide the substantive issue.” Equally, Peter Woolley, professor of political science and director of the PublicMind Poll, posited “in making this ruling on such narrow grounds, the court virtually guarantees that plaintiff in one guise or another will be back another day.”".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wikiPageExternalLink 2010_09_987.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wikiPageExternalLink arizona-christian-school-tuition-organization-v-winn-garriott-v-winn.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wikiPageExternalLink 09-987.htm.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wikiPageExternalLink 09-991.htm.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wikiPageExternalLink argument_audio_detail.aspx?argument=09-987.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wikiPageID "29519504".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wikiPageRevisionID "601237011".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn arguedate "--11-03".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn argueyear "2010".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn decidedate "--04-04".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn decideyear "2011".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn dissent "Kagan".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn docket "9".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn fullname "Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization, Petitioner v. Kathleen M. Winn, et al.; Gale Garriott, Director, Arizona Department of Revenue, Petitioner v. Kathleen M. Winn, et al.".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn hasPhotoCollection Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn holding "Taxpayers lack standing under Article III because they are challenging a tax credit, rather than government spending. 9th Circuit Reversed".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn joindissent "Breyer, Sotomayor, Ginsburg".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn joinmajority "Roberts, Scalia, Thomas, Alito".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn litigants "Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v. Winn".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn majority "Kennedy".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn oralargument argument_audio_detail.aspx?argument=09-987.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn parallelcitations "131".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn prior "17280.0".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn scotus "2010".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn uspage "___".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn usvol "563".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn subject Category:2011_in_United_States_case_law.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn subject Category:Establishment_Clause_case_law.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn subject Category:United_States_Supreme_Court_cases.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn subject Category:United_States_Supreme_Court_cases_of_the_Roberts_Court.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn type Case.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn type LegalCase.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn type SupremeCourtOfTheUnitedStatesCase.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn type UnitOfWork.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn type Situation.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn comment "Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v. Winn, 09-987, was a case decided by the Supreme Court of the United States. The case was consolidated with Gale Garriott, Director, Arizona Department of Revenue, Petitioner v. Kathleen M. Winn, et al. (09-991).A group of Arizona taxpayers challenged a state law providing tax credits to people who donate to school tuition organizations providing scholarships to students attending private or religious schools.".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn label "Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v. Winn".
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn sameAs m.0ds1zwc.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn sameAs Q4791271.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn sameAs Q4791271.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn wasDerivedFrom Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn?oldid=601237011.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn isPrimaryTopicOf Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn.
- Arizona_Christian_School_Tuition_Organization_v._Winn name "Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization, Petitioner v. Kathleen M. Winn, et al.; Gale Garriott, Director, Arizona Department of Revenue, Petitioner v. Kathleen M. Winn, et al.".